Meta, the tech behemoth behind Facebook and Instagram, is under fire for potentially using books, including those by Gerry Adams, without permission to train its AI models. An investigation revealed that Meta may have accessed millions of pirated books and research papers through LibGen (Library Genesis) to train its Llama AI system. Adams has already consulted his solicitor over this matter.
While Meta claims its use of information is consistent with existing law and respects third-party intellectual property rights, authors are outraged. A database of pirated books on LibGen revealed that numerous authors, including several from Northern Ireland like Jan Carson and Anna Burns, had their works listed.
Michael Taylor, a historian, expressed his fury, stating that Meta’s actions amount to the “single greatest and the most lucrative act of theft in history.” Prof Monica McWilliams highlighted the ethical concerns, questioning what copyright even means anymore, especially since she donates royalties to domestic violence charities.
Author Glenn Patterson called it a “clear infringement,” urging MPs to take notice. Claire Allan, a Londonderry author, expressed her devastation at seeing her entire body of work scraped to train AI.
Authors protested in London, with figures like Richard Osman demanding Meta seek permission before using copyrighted material. Osman stated copyright law is not complicated and if you use it without permission you’re breaking the law. The controversy surrounds Llama, an AI model that, while powerful, raises questions about data sourcing and ethical use, prompting a wider debate about compensating creatives for their work in the AI age.